Refine Search
Sort by
4500 Butterfly Shell Drive, Upper Captiva
$1,695,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026048193 MLS
Escape to the PEACE, QUIET & PRIVACY of North Captiva Island, where the roads are sand, the only traffic is golf carts, and the only way here is by ferry, boat or plane! Built in 2022 and set on one of the higher parts of the island, 4500 Butterfly Shell sits on an 80 x 110 lot wrapped in native vegetation located just over 750 ft from the beach access to the pristine white sands & turquoise water of the Gulf. Built to last on concrete pilings w/ a metal roof, Hardie board siding & impact-resistant windows & doors, this home was designed for years of low-maintenance Florida living. The home features 4 bedrooms & 4 full baths in the popular “UPSIDE-DOWN” floor plan, which puts the living area up top to catch the tropical breezes & views while keeping the bedrooms downstairs for when you retire for the night. The 2nd living level offers: kitchen & open living area w/ volume ceilings, 8 ft sliders out to a screened balcony, a bedroom & full bath, plus GULF & BAY VIEWS from nearly every window. From the screened patio area, a spiral staircase takes you up to the ROOFTOP DECK (crow’s nest) w/ panoramic views of the Gulf & Pine Island Sound and the surrounding island, and some of Florida’s most spectacular sunsets! The 1st living level offers: a nice foyer entry, impressive 10 ft ceilings, laundry & 3 spacious bedrooms, each w/ its own private en-suite bath. The fully screened ground level is the ultimate outdoor game room & gathering space w/ pool table, shuffleboard & hammocks. Step outside to a heated saltwater pool & spa, elegant paver deck, poolside bar & full privacy fencing, all made for relaxing or entertaining. Island amenities are just over 700 yards away by golf cart: Mainstays & Barnacles Bar, Mango’s Bar & Grill, Over the Waterfront, Anchors Landing & Coconuts Tiki Bar, plus the Island Market for groceries, coffee, ice cream & essentials, and a boat & retail shop. Love the water? World class fishing is at your fingertips plus Cabbage Key, Boca Grande and Cayo Costa State Park are all a short boat ride away! Enjoy the marina, boat rentals, fishing & kayak charters, and private clubs you can join w/ pickleball & tennis. With protected preserve land & some of the best coastal wildlife viewing in Florida, this is island life the way it was meant to be! This is GREAT opportunity for rental income, a second home or both all far from the hustle and bustle of city life! Call today to schedule your private showing!

4500 Butterfly Shell Drive, Upper Captiva

4441 Butterfly Shell Drive, Upper Captiva
$119,000
2026047623 MLS
BUILD YOUR NORTH CAPTIVA ISLAND DREAM on this fantastic location! Discover the possibilities at this island building lot where you can create your own custom coastal retreat surrounded by the natural beauty and relaxed atmosphere of North Captiva Island. Just two rows of homes from the island's expansive nature preserve in two different directions, you will enjoy a wonderful location close to scenic walking trails and convenient beach access just down the street, connecting you to miles of beautiful sugar-sand beaches. Imagine designing a home with spacious outdoor decks, breezy screened porches, tropical gardens, and inviting spaces to gather with family and friends. A thoughtfully designed elevated home might capture Gulf and Bay views from a rooftop lookout, with the potential for spectacular sunset views over the island. Whether your vision includes a private pool, generous outdoor entertaining areas, or a peaceful getaway to escape the everyday, this homesite is an exciting place to begin planning your island lifestyle. Spend your mornings walking the beautiful Gulf beaches, afternoons swimming and shelling, and evenings watching the sunset paint the sky from your future island retreat. North Captiva is a boat-access-only barrier island known for its uncrowded sandy beaches, protected natural areas, excellent boating and fishing, and wonderfully laid-back atmosphere. Here, golf carts replace cars, nature takes center stage, and every day offers another opportunity to slow down and enjoy coastal living. Whether you're planning a personal vacation retreat, a future island residence, or a custom home designed around your vision, 4441 Butterfly Shell Dr combines beach proximity, preserve access, and exciting Gulf, Bay, and sunset views in a beautiful island setting. Start imagining the possibilities and take the first step toward your North Captiva island dream!

4441 Butterfly Shell Drive, Upper Captiva

4560 Butterfly Shell Drive, Captiva
$395,000
2026039829 MLS
Build your dream island retreat at 4560 Butterfly Shell Dr on North Captiva Island, where architectural plans by Bud Lawrence have already been created for a stunning custom home designed specifically for this homesite. Located just a short walk from the Gulf, this property offers the opportunity to bring a thoughtfully designed island home to life while enjoying everything that makes North Captiva so special. Accessible only by boat or ferry, the island offers a true escape from the mainland with no cars and no bridges. Golf carts, sandy roads, miles of beaches, boating, fishing, shelling and unforgettable Gulf sunsets are all part of everyday life here. North Captiva also offers more than just the beach. Cruise over to Mango’s for lunch or a drink, stop by Coconuts for a laid-back island atmosphere, enjoy waterfront dining at Over the Waterfront, or grab essentials and island favorites without ever leaving the island. Ferry service from Pine Island makes getting to and from North Captiva convenient while still preserving the secluded feel that makes the island so unique. With Bud Lawrence home plans already prepared, 4560 Butterfly Shell Dr gives the next owner a head start toward creating a custom North Captiva residence. Whether envisioned as a private getaway, vacation home or future island retreat, this is an opportunity to own and build in one of Southwest Florida’s most distinctive barrier-island communities.

4560 Butterfly Shell Drive, Captiva

4490 Oyster Shell Drive, Upper Captiva
$1,450,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 2026030979 MLS
High-performing, income-producing vacation rental on one of North Captiva Island's premier streets. Privately nestled among mature tropical landscaping, this beautifully maintained 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath island retreat offers over 2,300 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space and a proven history of strong rental performance. Guests are drawn to the resort-style outdoor living, featuring an exceptionally large private pool, hot tub and outdoor shower, multiple entertaining areas, and a spectacular southwest-facing third-floor lanai that fully opens to the living room, creating a seamless indoor/outdoor living experience. Two en-suite bedrooms, a bunk room with a third bath, and a fourth queen suite provide ideal accommodations for owners and guests alike. Recent upgrades include Hardie Plank siding, two HVAC systems, Trex decking, a Brazilian hardwood pool deck, a cargo/luggage lift, and a paver driveway. A rare opportunity to own a turnkey island property that combines exceptional rental income, lush tropical privacy, premium outdoor amenities, and one of North Captiva's most desirable locations.

4490 Oyster Shell Drive, Upper Captiva

4481 Butterfly Shell Drive, Captiva
$949,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026029804 MLS
Fabulous North Captiva Island Opportunity! Welcome to the “The Perfect Shell,” a Fabulous Turnkey Furnished Gulf-side Beach Home featuring a private heated saltwater pool, no HOA or club membership fees, very impressive rental property with over 150+ FIVE STAR guest reviews! Situated on a desirable high-and-dry lot in Captiva Dunes, this custom stilt home is just a short walk or golf-cart ride to the sugar-sand shoreline of Sunset Beach, renowned for spectacular sunsets, shelling, fishing, swimming and sandbars! Surrounding lots may be available for purchase, offering an opportunity for added privacy or expansion directly across from and to the left of the home for a Prime Island Street and Island Location! Inquire on STRAP: 05-45-21-08-00000.0350 & 05-45-21-08-00000.0090. Inside, a bright, open great-room floor plan captures tropical views and opens to an expansive screened front balcony with sliders, ceiling fan and recessed lighting. The home offers 2 bedrooms and 1.5 baths and is sold turnkey furnished with lovely furnishings, fixtures and window coverings. The kitchen features a long breakfast bar, Corian countertops, recessed lighting, appliances and gas range. The primary bedroom includes a large closet. The main bath offers a large tiled shower and Corian-topped vanity. The half bath includes a sink, extensive built-in cabinetry, countertops and full-size stacked washer/dryer, with potential for a second full bath if desired. Appraisal in Hand and Second Story Architectural Plans in Hand "as applicable" should you want to expand in the future to this custom beach home. Outside, the large heated saltwater pool features built-in seating shelves, aluminum fencing and expansive brick-paver decking with wonderful sun exposure. A generous side yard provides additional outdoor space, while the spacious under-house area offers possibilities for entertaining—add an outdoor shower, changing area, bath, bar or outdoor kitchen. Enjoy tropical surroundings, exceptional outdoor living and easy access to one of North Captiva’s most beautiful beaches. Simply a must-see! Recent improvements and features include a 2024 white standing-seam metal roof, 2023 HVAC, 2025 exterior paint, 2023 whole-house reverse-osmosis system, hurricane-impact windows and doors, Hardie-board siding, tile throughout and attached ground-level garage. For buyers interested in vacation-rental income, The Perfect Shell has an established rental history with many repeat annual guests. The property is professionally managed, with continued management available. Whether you're looking for your own North Captiva getaway, private permanent island pool home, an established income-producing property, or a combination of personal enjoyment and rental potential, this exceptional island home delivers! Experience a Showing at The Perfect Shell, you will be glad you did! 2026 Appraisal in Hand!

4481 Butterfly Shell Drive, Captiva

4580 OYSTER SHELL DR & 370 TOWNHOUSE Lane Unit 60, Upper Captiva
$865,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026020831 MLS
Dock your boat and enjoy water views from an end-unit townhome, while you build your dream home on an incredible lot with direct views toward the beach and Gulf! Introducing a unique island ownership combination: Townhome #60 at 370 Townhouse Ln (Parcel ID: 05-45-21-03-00000.0600) in Safety Harbor Club, paired with a separate buildable homesite at 4580 Oyster Shell Dr, offered together as an exceptional package. The townhome offers immediate enjoyment with beautiful harbor views, shared community dockage steps away, and full access to all Safety Harbor Club amenities, including a heated pool, tennis courts, pickleball, clubhouse, dining, convenient ferry landing, and private Gulf beach access. Perfectly positioned within Safety Harbor Club, the townhome provides an ideal home base for boating, beach days, and island living, with rental or personal-use flexibility. Included in this package is 4580 Oyster Shell Dr, a valuable homesite with incredible views!  You will be stunned by the amazing view corridor looking down onto the sugar-sand beach and sparkling Gulf waters beyond.  Imagine watching the sun set every night right from your living room. This lot plus townhome combination is a must-see!

4580 OYSTER SHELL DR & 370 TOWNHOUSE Lane Unit 60, Upper Captiva

4491 Butterfly Shell Drive, Upper Captiva
$249,900
2026015519 MLS
Build your Island Dream Home on this tropical homesite located in the desirable North Captiva Dunes neighborhood! The high elevation, which provides peace of mind from storms, combined with the scenic view corridor toward the water and the Preserve, sets this lot apart. Located approximately 900 feet from the wide sugar sand Sunset Beach, this property enjoys a prime location with only two rows of homes between you and the sparkling Gulf waters. Enjoy the sounds of the surf with spectacular views from the upper stories & the lookout of your newly designed masterpiece. Just around the corner from all the preserve trails, and a short golf cart ride to the island’s resort hub with dining, pools, and recreation. North Captiva Island is a private, boat-access-only barrier island known for its friendly vacation vibe, protected natural areas, and relaxed golf-cart lifestyle. With miles of pristine beaches, exceptional fishing, and abundant wildlife, the island provides a unique coastal experience unlike anywhere else in Florida. Vacant land opportunities with this combination of elevation, location, and view potential in this part of the island are rare. Secure your place on North Captiva and begin planning your custom island vacation retreat today!

4491 Butterfly Shell Drive, Upper Captiva

4510 Oyster Shell Drive, Upper Captiva
$1,300,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026013122 MLS
Elevated Living, Gulf Views & Rooftop Sunsets Imagine pulling up in your golf cart, the breeze already shifting as you arrive at a home set high and dry in one of North Captiva's most sought-after neighborhoods. 4510 Oyster Shell Dr is a 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath retreat with an additional 4th sleeping room, designed to make the most of island life. The reverse floorplan captures Gulf views and coastal light from the moment you step into the main living level. Upstairs, the open-concept living, dining, and kitchen area feels bright, easy, and inviting—perfect for gathering after a day at the beach or hosting friends for a laid-back island evening. Large windows and elevated positioning bring the outdoors in, while the surrounding landscape and water views remind you exactly why you're here. And just down the sandy lane lies one of the island's true treasures—a premier beach access point leading to North Captiva's widest stretch of powder-soft, sugar-white sand. This is the kind of beach people travel across the world to find—expansive, uncrowded, and endlessly walkable—where mornings begin with quiet shoreline strolls and evenings end with unforgettable Gulf sunsets. Then there's the rooftop lookout—one of those features that quietly becomes your favorite place. Morning coffee surrounded by water views as the island wakes up… sunset cocktails as the sky turns gold… and quiet nights under a blanket of stars with the preserve stretching out below. Recent upgrades, including a new metal roof, Hardie board siding, and aluminum railings, add both durability and a clean coastal finish. Positioned along one of the island's highest ridgelines—with elevated construction and storm shutters—the home offers an added sense of confidence and comfort. This isn't just a vacation home—it's a place where beach days feel effortless, sunsets feel personal, and every visit makes it harder to leave. Come see it for yourself—and picture where your mornings, beach walks, and next chapter could begin.

4510 Oyster Shell Drive, Upper Captiva

751 Rum Road, Upper Captiva
$430,000
2025022211 MLS
Sunrise and Sunset Views from this Rare Estate Lot bordering the 350 Acre State Preserve on North Captiva Island! Imagine building your dream home on this lot, where every day you can see glowing sunrises over acres of palm trees and seagrapes, and in the evenings, admire the Gulf sunsets painting the sky. Bordering protected state park land, this lot offers exceptional privacy, uninterrupted sightlines, and a front-row seat to island wildlife. Osprey flights at dawn, flocks of pelicans soaring past, flying in formation, glimpses of the local bald eagles, and the soft hush of nature all around you. On this property, the landscape doesn’t just surround you… it embraces you. Take a short stroll or golf cart ride down the street to one of the most expansive stretches of sugar sand on the island. The entrance to the state preserve hiking and biking trails is just a few hundred feet away. Very few vacant parcels on North Captiva combine preserve frontage, panoramic water views, estate-level space, and both sunrise and sunset vistas, making this a unique and wonderful place to enjoy your new island life.

751 Rum Road, Upper Captiva

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!